Weekend Cinema Listomania (Special War is Sorta Hell! Edition)

posted November 21, 2008 8:41 AM

The General ultimate two disc edition cover.jpg

DVD Event of the Week: Is it Disney's five seperate editions (Blu-ray and DVD) of Pixar's incomparable Wall-E? Or perhaps BBC Warner's Doctor Who: The Complete Fourth Series starring David Tennant? Or are we talking about Kino International's staggering five disc box set Griffith Masterworks 2, featuring Way Down East and the long out of print documentary D.W. Griffith: Father of Film?

All worthy, to be sure, for my money it's got to be Kino's concurrent Buster Keaton/The General: Ultimate 2 Disc Edition.

As the title suggests, this is an expanded version of a previous Kino package, and as before, its centerpiece is a virtually flawless HD transfer from a 35mm archive print struck from the original camera negative. This time, however, you also get a second disc with some quite wonderful bonuses -- a montage of train gags throughtout Keaton's career, a tour of the actual locations used in the film, and another tour of the authentic General, the Civil War era locomotive of the title.

Of course, none of this would mean much if the film itself wasn't so great; it is, in fact, the silent cinema pretty much at its peak. The story of a young Southerner (Keaton) who's rejected by the Confederate army as unfit and taken for a coward by his girlfriend, it ultimately turns into a brilliantly realized combination of action movie, behind the lines spy drama and slapstick comedy, all photographed and art directed to look like Matthew Brady photos come to life. It's one of those films that if it comes on TV, no matter how many times you've seen it you inevitably get hooked again; here's Kino's trailer for the new edition for a little taste.

As you can see, Keaton is an absolutely mesmeric presence, hilariously, albeit drily, funny and preternaturally beautifully, but as you can hear, there's yet another reason to recommend the set -- the glorious symphonic orchestral score by Carl Davis. Davis pretty much cornered the market on composing new music for vintage silent films in the 80s and early 90s; The General score here was recorded for a Thames Video/HBO restoration in '87, and it's been out of print for at least since the end of the laserdisc era. Kino also offers you the option of choosing a more than serviceable chamber score by Robert Israel and an organ score by theater veteran Lee Irwin, but the Davis soundtrack is the one you'll want to feature, especialy in the new 5.1. surround mix. (And here's hoping Kino resurrects some of Davis' other silent scores, in particular the amazing one for the 1927 Victor Sjöström masterpiece The Wind).

In any case, you can and most very definitely should, order the set here.

Okay, that said, and since things will likely be quiet around here for a couple of days, here's a hopefully amusing little project for us all:

Most Memorable Action/Adventure Set During Wartime!!!

And my totally top of my head Top Five is:

5. The Guns of Navarone (J. Lee Thompson,1961)
A ragtag group (Americans, Brits, Poles, Kiwis) of Allied commandos try to blow up an apparently impregnable German fortress. Mad Magazine famously parodied it as The Guns of Minnestrone.

4. The Secret Invasion (Roger Corman, 1964 )
A ragtag group (Americans, Brits) of Allied commandos try to break a turncoat Italian general out of a Nazi prison. With Edd "Kookie" Byrnes, so you know it's got to be good.

3. Castle Keep (Sydney Pollack, 1969)
A ragtag group of American soldiers takes refuge in a spooky castle whose owner, a Count played by Jean-Pierre Aumont , hopes they'll protect it from the Germans.

2. The Keep (Michael Mann,1983)
A ragtag group of German commandos....Actually, I have no idea who does what in this; it seems to be more of a horror film than an action/adventure, but it's so wonderfully incoherent you can't be sure. In any case, it's superficially a remake of Castle Keep even though it really isn't. Okay, it's a mess...I just slipped it on the list as a ringer, and here's the equally incoherent trailer.

And the number one coolest wartime action/adventure flick, it's not even close you knuckleheads so just shut up and keep reading, obviously is

1. The Fastest Guitar Alive (Michael D. Moore,1967 )
A ragtag group of....No, just Roy Orbison, cast (shall we say) against type, as a Confederate spy with a bullet-shooting guitar given the task of robbing gold bullion from the United States Mint in San Francisco, With songs! Produced by the beyond immortal Sam Katzman!! What are you waiting for, fercrissakes?

Awrighty now -- what would your choices be?

23 Comments

The Phantom Creep said:

Dude -- I realize you're being ironic and all, but "The Keep" really sucks.

November 21, 2008 6:01 AM

Meander said:

"Beautiful" was never a word that I used in thinking of Buster Keaton, but he was lovely and graceful in "The General".

Dog Soldiers isn't in wartime (technically), but it's all hardcore military vs. werewolves.

November 21, 2008 6:04 AM

ProfWombat said:

'The Keep' was a poorly made mess of a movie, taken from a book I much admire by F. Paul Wilson. I especially admired the book's evocation of horror not with blood and gore, but with human frailty, the notion of levels of evil more complex and deep than necessary or contemporary, and the ambiguity of result at the end.

Wilson's been mining the same material for a couple decades since 'The Keep', with spotty results. I keep reading him, hoping for the same level of craft, and am generally disappointed...

November 21, 2008 6:07 AM

dave™© said:

A friend and I have long incorporated a punchline from the "Dick Van Dyke Show" into the fabric of our lives: "You SLEPT through 'The Guns of Navarone'???"

November 21, 2008 7:04 AM

BlakNo1 said:

Don't waste your time with Twilight. See Let The Right One In instead, most unique vampire movie I've ever seen and the best one since Near Dark.

November 21, 2008 7:06 AM

Brooklyn Girl said:

Seriously? "The Great Escape."

November 21, 2008 8:52 AM

fmcg said:

The Train. Frankenheimer directing, Scofield, Moreau, Lancaster...just terrific.

November 21, 2008 9:03 AM

fmcg said:

"The Train." Frankenheimer directing Lancaster, Moreau, Scofield...it's just terrific.

November 21, 2008 9:06 AM

kurt b. said:

Yes to "The General" but am I the only one who thinks "Our Hospitality" is the funniest Keaton feature?

And Melville's "Army of Shadows" for most memorable wartime adventure flick.

November 21, 2008 11:52 AM

Anonymous said:

Most memorable : the first 1/2 hour of SAVING PRIVATE RYAN -

The Dirty Dozen


November 21, 2008 12:16 PM

Anonymous said:

Das Boot - directed by wolfgang peterson
Paths Of Glory - Stanley Kubrick

November 21, 2008 12:24 PM

Allan Rosenberg said:

Full Metal Jacket
Dr. Strangelove (There's a war raging by the end!!!)
Apocalypse Now
Kelly's Heroes (I think it's mostly silly but it's my wife's favorite war movie)

I agree with the first 1/2 hour of Saving Private Ryan but the last 1/2 hour of action is also great.

November 21, 2008 2:59 PM

Culture of Truth said:

It took a week but I finally posted my best spoof movies.


They are what you would expect, except for Zelig which is an oft overlooked spoof film.


Most war pictures have some action, but if you are thinking of more lightheated fare set in wartime, as the term "Adventure" implies, then that changes things somewhat.


* Raiders of the Lost Ark


* Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade


* M*A*S*H


And the winner, I mean really, no matter how you categorize it . . .


* Lawrence of Arabia

.

November 21, 2008 3:12 PM

Culture of Truth said:

Funny there aren't more set in the Cold War, which would seem to lend itself to action/adventure treatment. Unless I just can't think of one. There are the Bond films, of course, but then I suppose there is something gloomy and dark about an undeclared war based mostly on subterfuge and deception.


Is Catch 22 action / adventure? Is Patton too serious?


Ever seen Ride with the Devil? Also set in the Civil War, lots of stars, directed by Ang Lee. Worth checking out.


What's the buzz on Valkyire? I'm afraid to ask.

November 21, 2008 3:26 PM

Steve Simels said:

BlakNo1 said:

Don't waste your time with Twilight. See Let The Right One In instead, most unique vampire movie I've ever seen and the best one since Near Dark.

I've been hearing good things on that. And if you're comparing it to Near Dark I'm extremely interested.

November 21, 2008 8:10 PM

Steve Simels said:

Culture of Truth:

I'm a big fan of "Ride With the Devil."
http://movies.tvguide.com/ride-devil/review/134129

November 21, 2008 8:14 PM

Steve Simels said:

kurt b. said:

Yes to "The General" but am I the only one who thinks "Our Hospitality" is the funniest Keaton feature?

No. I totally agree.

And the great video version of "Our Hospitality" was another '87 HBO/Thames restoration featuring a score by....Carl Davis.

Also out of print, I believe. Hopefully Kino will resurrect it...

November 21, 2008 8:18 PM

The Kenosha Kid said:

The Great Escape, of course

The Eagle has Landed - a ragtag group of Germans who AREN'T NAZIS try to assassinate Churchill..

Buffalo Soldiers - a ragtag group of half-wit soldiers cook meth in the barracks...

Biloxi Blues - a ragtag group of soldiers try to get laid...

November 22, 2008 8:38 AM

irving R. Irving said:

Carl Davis also did the score for the Brownlow restoration of Gance's Napoleon. When Coppola bought the American rights, he 86d it and had his father (in law?) Carmine write an inferior one. I believe the European DVDs have Davis' score, and I'm pretty sure excerpts from it are on CD somewhere.

November 23, 2008 7:35 AM

Libby said:

On the off chance this comment will register if I don't sign up, I'll nominate some classics.

Desperate Journey - Errol Flynn
Sergeant York - Gary Cooper
Lawrence of Arabia - Peter O'Toole
Sahara - Humphrey Bogart

November 23, 2008 10:07 AM

Irving R. Irving said:

I second Libby's nomination of Sahara. A real nail-biter, and one of Bogart's best I think.

November 23, 2008 10:19 AM

Who Am Us Anyway said:

Good picks, Culture of Truth. Steve, good on you for being in the distinct minority of critics to like Ride with the Devil, a movie that flat out knocked me out. I remember being frustrated to read poor after absurdly poor review of a movie that I thought was so smart, so well done, & so true to Missouri history. I liked it even better than Cold Mountain, which I also liked.

November 23, 2008 3:52 PM

rosa said:

As a photographer I can't resist mentioning Salvador.

November 24, 2008 7:41 PM

Leave a comment