Weekend Cinema Listmania (Special Churchy La Femme Edition)
posted July 3, 2009 4:04 AM
Video Event of the Week: Is it Sony's new DVD of The Strange One, a rarely seen gays-in-the-military drama with Ben Gazarra and George Peppard? Could Disney's disc of The Jonas Brothers: The 3D Experience concert flick possibly get the nod? Or is there even the slightest chance that Fox's Blu-ray of 12 Rounds, the latest action flick starring wrestler John Cena and directed by the increasingly risible Renny Harlin, possibly be The One?
All worthy, to be sure (well, not that last, obviously) but for my money it's got to be Warner's remastered version of M Butterfly, David Cronenberg's 1993 adaptation of the sex role-bending stage play by David Henry Hwang .
Actually, this has been out for a couple of weeks, but cut me some slack -- there's been a lot of stuff to ponder of late. Besides, I wanted to write about it because Cronenberg is currently having one of the most interesting third acts of any big deal Hollywood director in memory and (to be honest) I missed this when it first came out theatrically.
The story (inspired by a true incident) is, of course, a fascinating one, with Jeremy Irons playing a married French diplomat, stationed in Beijing in 1964, who finds himself falling head over heels for a Chinese opera performer (John Lone of The Last Emperor) that he believes is a woman. The gender-f**k theme gets played out against the backdrop of history -- the brutal Chinese Cultural Revolution of the 60s intrudes in terrifying fashion -- and playwright Hwang's script also deals, rather wittily, with the biases of both of the protagonists (Lone's character is actually a bit of a bigot). There's also an obvious metaphorical what-is-reality? element here, and the duo's relationship has hall-of-mirrors parallels to that of the Puccini opera that provides the title.
Here's the trailer to give you a little taste.
Critics (and audiences, apparently) back in the day seem to have been flummoxed by the fact that Lone is obviously a guy, but I must say I don't see that as a problem; he's so gorgeous and so seductive (his vaguely Peter Lorre-ish accent is a hoot) that it doesn't strike me, at least, as unlikely that some nerdish functionary could tumble for him and remain in denial about his gender. In any case there's no doubt whatsoever that the character as Irons plays him is absolutely, and rather heartbreakingly, gaga. Actually, my only cavil with the piece is that Hwang really hasn't opened it up all that much and that despite Cronenberg's best efforts it remains a tad stage-bound, although the director does manage some visuals (in the opera scenes, in particular) that will haunt your imagination.
That said, this is one of those films that I think is definitely due for re-evaluation. Warner's new transfer, I'm happy to report, is quite spectacular, with almost eye-popping color and detail (the stylized animated credits sequence is worth the price of admission) and rich, enveloping surround sound (the better to experience yet another supremely effective score by long-time Cronenberg collaborator Howard Shore, who may be the most underrated and versatile film composer currently working). There's also a very interesting new interview with Cronenberg, who talks at some length about why a guy (at the time) mostly identified with horror and related genres was drawn to the project; as he points out, many (if not all) of his earlier films, particularly The Fly and Dead Ringers, were also about the nature of identity.
Bottom line -- a fascinating film and an exemplary package. You can -- and definitely should -- order it here.

And since things are going to be relatively quiet around here until Monday, here's a fun and obviously relevant project for us all to contemplate --
Most Memorable Film Featuring a Shady Dame (Male OR Female)!!!
And my totally top of my head Top Five is:
5. Out of the Past (Jacques Tourneur, 1947)
The divine Jane Greer, my favorite film noir babe, betraying Robert Mitchum, Kirk Douglas and everybody else in sight. Talk about kiss me deadly.
4. Detour (Edgar G. Ulmer, 1945)
The divinely rumpled (and scary as hell) Ann Savage, my second favorite film noir babe, proving that Sartre was right -- hell IS other people -- in Ulmer's beyond remarkable low-budget thriller. BTW, Savage showed up last year in Guy Maddin's My Winnipeg, which definitely behooves beholding.
3. D.O.A. (Rudolph Mate, 1950)

Top-billed Edmund O'Brien is Frank Bigelow, a poor sap who's been fatally slow poisoned and has two days to find his murderer. But the character that really does it for me is Marla Rakubian, a femme fatale played by the memorably ripe Laurette Luez who may or may not be up to her pretty little neck in the conspiracy. The coolest plot in all of noir, obviously, and it occasions some pretty snappy dialogue as well.
Marla: If I were a man, I'd punch your dirty face in!
Frank: You know I really believe you would!
2. Dressed to Kill (Brian de Palma, 1980)

The Citizen Kane of transvestite killer shrink movies, and every bit as good as as that sounds. That's Michael Caine under the wig, in case you haven't seen this uniquely over-the-top genre exercise, which (perhaps tellingly) also features de Palma's then wife Nancy Allen as a sleazy hooker.
And the most memorable film featuring some "woman" you shouldn't trust as far as you can throw "her," self-evidently is ---
1. The Black Bird (David Giler, 1975)

Chabrol, Buñuel and Rohmer muse Stéphane Audran is the beautiful and androgynous daughter of the Russian general who once owned the real Maltese Falcon in a comedy sequel to the Bogart classic. For what it's worth, I seem to be the only person in the world who thinks this film is a hoot, but I think there's one thing we can all agree on -- Audran has quite the most astonishing cheek bones.
Awrighty -- and your choices would be????
11 Comments
Leave a comment

Steve Simels has written about music and movies for Sound and Vision magazine (formerly Stereo Review) since the early 70s. He has also contributed to Entertainment Weekly, TV Guide and the Wall Street Journal. He’s the author of “Gender Chameleons: Androgyny in Rock n Roll” (Arbor House, 1985), and blogs at PowerPop.blogspot.com. His ambition in life is to play the Leslie Howard role in a remake of “Petrified Forest.”

Weekend Cinema Listomania (Special They Walk Among Us! Edition)
Proof of the Existence of God (An Occasional Series)
Great Lost Films of the Nineties (An Occasional Series): Special Germans Behaving Badly Edition
Christmas Comes But Once a Year (The Return of a Recurring Series)
How Bad Could It Be? (An Occasional Series): In Praise of Older Women
Weekend Cinema Listomania (Special Slacker Halloween Edition)
The French They Are a Funny Race...
Scenes From an Unwritten Screenplay: Jeanne Samary et Moi
Scenes From an Unwritten Screenplay: The Mystery of Victor Noir
Weekend Cinema Listomania (Special Rico Suave! Edition)
If It's Thursday, It Must Be Shameless Parisian Filler
Haven't the Jews Suffered Enough? (An Occasional Series): Part II

Gummo said:
Ah, steve, I would still go for the original: Mary Astor in The Maltese Falcon. There's a shady dame who would say anything, do anything to get what she wanted. Cold, calculating, measuring up every man she comes in contact with so she can discern his weak point & work it to her advantage, a consummate liar, conscienceless -- ah, they don't make'em like that anymore.
July 3, 2009 6:53 AM
Gwen De Marco said:
Critics (and audiences, apparently) back in the day seem to have been flummoxed by the fact that Lone is obviously a guy, but I must say I don't see that as a problem; he's so gorgeous and so seductive (his vaguely Peter Lorre-ish accent is a hoot) that it doesn't strike me, at least, as unlikely that some nerdish functionary could tumble for him and remain in denial about his gender.
The same could be said for what's-his-name in "The Crying Game" ...
As for the category, I'd go with Mary Astor in the original "Maltese Falcon" but she just never struck me as sexy enough, so instead I'll nominate Barbara Stanwyck in "Double Indemnity".
July 3, 2009 7:04 AM
Sid Sherman said:
Anybody ever see Sidney Lumet's great cop movie Q&A, with Nick Nolte? There's a black drag queen in that -- you don't find out she's a woman till near the end -- who's quite impressive, if that's the word. If memory serves, she was a fairly famous downtown NYC drag star.
July 3, 2009 8:19 AM
David Derbes said:
I'm wit' Gummo. Briget O'Shaugnessy is as fatale a femme as ever drew breath.
However, Kathleen Turner in Body Heat ain't half harmful, neither.
July 3, 2009 8:30 AM
Terry C - Castrating B*tch said:
Barbara Stanwyck in "Double Indemnity".
And in "The File on Thelma Jordan."
July 3, 2009 9:54 AM
Mufungo said:
Re: "obviously a guy": Cronenberg addresses this issue during a bonus interview on the current DVD; his comments weren't a huge revelation, but did give me a bit of a different perspective on the story.
Oh, adding Lana Turner in The Postman Always Rings Twice to everyone else's great picks.
July 3, 2009 11:26 AM
Steve Simels said:
Mofungo:
Actually, in the interview, Cronenberg addresses that issue mostly from the angle of having cast a recognizable actor -- John Lone, who was then pretty well known -- as the character rather than an unknown.
Interesting, in either case...
July 3, 2009 1:16 PM
Mufungo said:
Hmmm...I seem to remember a mention about the original case during his interview, and that contemporaries of the diplomat thought what critics of the movie did: "That's a MAN, baby!" Cronenberg then considered the diplomat as someone who wasn't "fooled" by the opera singer's disguise, but in denial about his own sexuality, at least in his public life.
Maybe I read into the interview more than was actually said. Anyhoo, enjoyed the flick.
July 3, 2009 3:29 PM
peter spencer said:
Sylvia Miles in "Midnight Cowboy"?
July 3, 2009 4:21 PM
Brooklyn Girl said:
Gail Sondergaard in "Spider Woman"
July 3, 2009 8:55 PM
Who Am Us Anyway said:
Drat. I don't know enough to add to the great femme fatale list already compiled here. but I am taking notes. Great Listmania category!
July 6, 2009 12:01 AM