One is the Loneliest Number
posted August 4, 2009 6:01 AM
Video Event of the Day: Well, it's a little slow for a Tuesday, but clearly it's Paramount's new DVD and Blu-ray versions of director Joe Wright's The Soloist -- the Esa-Pekka Salonen Robert Downey Jr./Jamie Foxx star vehicle that drops this morning, as the kids say.
Okay, Esa-Pekka Salonen and the LA Philharmonic actually are on the soundtrack. Sorry -- couldn't resist a little classical music joke there.
In any case, if you haven't seen it (or missed some of the pre-release hype earlier in the year, including a 60 Minutes profile of the real-life characters the film is based on), The Soloist is about cellist Nathaniel Ayers (Foxx), a musical prodigy who develops serious paranoid schizophrenic symptoms and winds up homeless on the streets. Downey, meanwhile, is Steve Lopez, an LA Times reporter with his own problems who befriends Ayers, and the relationship between the two ultimately changes their lives blah blah blah.
Here's a representative clip to give you a taste of the thing.
I saw this in the theater during its original run and seeing it again on Paramount's beautifully transfered DVD still leaves me underwhelmed. For starters, despite the fact that Ayers' and Lopez' story is as dramatic and heart-tugging as you could want, somebody -- more than likely screenwriter Susannah Grant -- felt the need to give the Lopez character all sorts of demons he not only lacked in real life but seem obviously shoe-horned in to up the drama quotient and create some kind of thematic equivalence between the two characters. It's a bogus contrivance and an annoying one, and it serves to set up the film's other major problem -- which is that despite yeoman work from Downey and Foxx, you're acutely conscious of the fact you're watching a film less intent on illuminating two interesting lives with a modicum of honesty than with a fairly blatant attempt to garner two Academy Award nominations. And if that sounds cynical, wait till you see the film.
That said, The Soloist is not at all bad on the politics of LA's treatment of the homeless, and I'd be remiss if I didn't add that despite its problems, it's worlds, perhaps even universes, better than another recent would-be inspirational blockbuster about the healing power of music. I refer, of course, to the astoundingly appalling 2007 August Rush, featuring kid actor Freddie Highmore using his adorableness as a cudgel and Robin Williams, doing an inexplicable impression of U2's Bono, in what may be the most fraudulent performance of his career.
Seriously -- if you got through that trailer without wanting to find director Kirsten Sheridan and slap her with a dead fish, you're a better person than I.
In any case, the DVD of The Soloist, which as I mentioned previously looks quite terrifc, comes with a couple of interesting if not revelatory bonuses, including deleted scenes and three (sort of) making-of documentaries, one of which addresses the issue of homelessness in LA specifically.
If any of that interests you -- and to be fair, Downey is probably always worth watching, as is co-star Catherine Keener -- you can order The Soloist over here.
5 Comments
Leave a comment

Steve Simels has written about music and movies for Sound and Vision magazine (formerly Stereo Review) since the early 70s. He has also contributed to Entertainment Weekly, TV Guide and the Wall Street Journal. He’s the author of “Gender Chameleons: Androgyny in Rock n Roll” (Arbor House, 1985), and blogs at PowerPop.blogspot.com. His ambition in life is to play the Leslie Howard role in a remake of “Petrified Forest.”

Weekend Cinema Listomania (Special In the Not Too Distant Future Edition)
Great Lost Babes of the Twenties (An Occasional Series)
If It's Tuesday, It Must Be Shameless Filler (Special Storefront Hitchcock Edition)
Christmas Comes But Once a Year (A Recurring Series): Let Us Now Praise Famous Alter Kakers
Weekend Cinema Listomania: Special Coming to America Edition
What's UP Doc: The Search For a Cleverer Headline
Christmas Comes But Once a Year (A Recurring Series): The Bird is the Word
How Bad Could It Be? (An Occasional Series): Short People Got No Reason to Live
Weekend Cinema Listomania (Special They Walk Among Us! Edition)
Proof of the Existence of God (An Occasional Series)
Great Lost Films of the Nineties (An Occasional Series): Special Germans Behaving Badly Edition
Christmas Comes But Once a Year (The Return of a Recurring Series)
How Bad Could It Be? (An Occasional Series): In Praise of Older Women

Gummo said:
I found the 60 Minutes piece to be very emotional and affecting, and the trailers for the movie to be very cynical, calculated and affected. Most of the reviews, including yours, agreed with me.
The producers would have been better off partnering with CBS and expanding the 60 Minutes piece into a full-length documentary.
August 4, 2009 6:49 AM
Nym Chomsky said:
August Rush may have been the most painful six weeks I ever spent at a movie. Okay, it only felt like six weeks, but still....
August 4, 2009 6:56 AM
Gwen De Marco said:
Robin Williams, doing an inexplicable impression of U2's Bono, in what may be the most fraudulent performance of his career.
I find a lot of Williams' performances fraudulent and lacking real emotional depth.
August 4, 2009 8:51 AM
DuaneV said:
Sorry. Last one of these "inspirational power of music" films I'll ever watch was "Mr. Holland's Opus"...I must be honest, though, having seen the '60 Minutes' piece, I found the clip with Downey and Foxx to be easily as insulting to my intelligence as the other clip...
August 4, 2009 10:27 AM
The Kenosha Kid said:
Is "Inspirational power of music" a genre that needs to die? Sister Act, Sister Act 2...
August 4, 2009 5:39 PM