How Bad Could It Be? (An Occasional Series): In Praise of Older Women
posted November 2, 2009 4:15 AM
Just finished watching the new Miramax DVD version of Chéri, the adaptation of the scandalous in its day (1920) novel, starring the still toothsome Michelle Pfeiffer and reuniting her with the Dangerous Liasons directing/writing team of Stephen Frears and Christopher Hampton. I missed this one in the theaters earlier this year (as did just about everybody else in the Western World for some reason) but I've had a thing for Pfeiffer since Grease 2, and if the film's older woman/younger man story line is a little too trendy for words at the moment (screw you, Demi Moore! Bite me, Courtney Cox's new sitcom!!!) it has the virtue of being based on the works of the great Colette, who was writing about the whole Cougar thing almost a century before it was cool. Plus Anita Pallenberg, the iconic 60s babe who boinked all five of the original Rolling Stones is in there somewhere, so I figured it might be worth a look.
You know -- how bad could it be?
The plot:
The place: Belle Époque Paris. Ravishing but past her prime courtesan Léa (Pfeiffer), former muse to the rich and famous, is contemplating her retirement options when archrival Madame Charlotte (Kathy Bates -- interesting casting, that) asks her to teach Fred (Rupert Friend), her spoiled rotten 19-year-old son (nicknamed Chéri), about women. What follows is a six-year affair whose intensity surprises them both (a fact complicated by the fact that the kid is a flamboyant esthete who wears silk pyjamas and Léa's pearls). But they both believe the relationship is casual until the kid is forced into an arranged marriage, at which point they realize (how do you say "duh!" in French?) they're actually in love. The remainder of the film is, as it says on the video box, " an adventure in which a boy who refuses to grow up collides with a woman who realizes she cannot stay young forever." Spoiler alert: This being a French story, it will not come as a complete shock that when Chéri finally figures out Léa was the only woman he could ever truly love, he does the only sensible thing and offs himself.
Okay, cutting to the chase, the answer to our earlier question is "Given the talent involved both on and off the screen, rather disappointingly not so good." On the plus side, the thing looks gorgeous, with several scenes staged like Post-Impressionist paintings come to life, and there's a truly lovely Neo-Classical score by Alexandre Desplat that adds immeasurably to the mood of languid, genteel decadence. Mostly, though, it's the kind of film that seems to consist mainly of unrealistically attractive people sitting around half-clothed exchanging brittle witticisms and eating strawberries, and as beautiful as Pfeiffer looks, she's (putting it kindly) out of her depth in the role; you're painfully conscious that you're watching somebody born and bred in California, if you know what I mean.
Here's the trailer to give you a vague idea of what an attractive misfire the whole thing is, although trust me -- the movie itself is nowhere near as light-hearted and comic.
The Miramax DVD version features a basically state of the art transfer; extras include the de rigeur deleted scenes (negligible) and the even more de rigeur making-of documentary (even more negligible).
In any case, you can (and I wouldn't necessarily ring your doorbell and run if you did) order Cheri over here.
7 Comments
Leave a comment

Steve Simels has written about music and movies for Sound and Vision magazine (formerly Stereo Review) since the early 70s. He has also contributed to Entertainment Weekly, TV Guide and the Wall Street Journal. He’s the author of “Gender Chameleons: Androgyny in Rock n Roll” (Arbor House, 1985), and blogs at PowerPop.blogspot.com. His ambition in life is to play the Leslie Howard role in a remake of “Petrified Forest.”

Weekend Cinema Listomania (Special In the Not Too Distant Future Edition)
Great Lost Babes of the Twenties (An Occasional Series)
If It's Tuesday, It Must Be Shameless Filler (Special Storefront Hitchcock Edition)
Christmas Comes But Once a Year (A Recurring Series): Let Us Now Praise Famous Alter Kakers
Weekend Cinema Listomania: Special Coming to America Edition
What's UP Doc: The Search For a Cleverer Headline
Christmas Comes But Once a Year (A Recurring Series): The Bird is the Word
How Bad Could It Be? (An Occasional Series): Short People Got No Reason to Live
Weekend Cinema Listomania (Special They Walk Among Us! Edition)
Proof of the Existence of God (An Occasional Series)
Great Lost Films of the Nineties (An Occasional Series): Special Germans Behaving Badly Edition
Christmas Comes But Once a Year (The Return of a Recurring Series)
How Bad Could It Be? (An Occasional Series): In Praise of Older Women

Sid Sherman said:
Pfeiffer looks beautiful, indeed, but isn't she a little skinny for the part? Seriously -- wouldn't a real babe of the period have had a little bit more of a belle poitrine, as the French say?
November 2, 2009 4:51 AM
Gwen De Marco said:
Blech.
Pfeiffer's voice is incredibly flat and annoying. As gorgeous as she is, it's hard to see why any man would find her hypnotically charming.
Compare to Francesca Annis as Lillie Langtry, for example ... unfortunately, this is the only clip on YouTube.
November 2, 2009 6:13 AM
Cousin Kevin said:
Oh, I dunno -- Lois from Family Guy is smoking hot, and she's got the most annoying voice in the world.
November 2, 2009 8:46 AM
Brett said:
I am with you on the Grease 2 front (for Pfeiffer and the movie). I write a column about "first" sequels and that one (along with Return to Witch Mountain) was very formative in my childhood. If I had to guess, I must have watched Grease 2 close to 30 times on HBO between 1982 and 1983 when I was six/seven. I rewatched it recently for the first time since then and was like "Yup! Exactly what a young impressionable boy might find fascinating :)"
November 2, 2009 10:41 AM
Gwen De Marco said:
Oh, I dunno -- Lois from Family Guy is smoking hot, and she's got the most annoying voice in the world.
True, but Lois also has some energy. Pfeiffer plays this like she's on Valium.
November 2, 2009 10:44 AM
peter spencer said:
All five? I heard that NOBODY got to Charlie.
November 2, 2009 11:25 AM
Steve Simels said:
Actually, I may have that wrong about Anita. But I'm pretty sure Marianne Faithfull did -- it's in her autobiography, if memory serves.
November 2, 2009 11:27 AM