4 Stars 5 Bucks

Disney's A Christmas Carol

by Pete Hammond

posted November 3, 2009 6:21 AM

Like seeing it for the first time

Technically far superior to his two previous directorial efforts in the Motion (a.k.a. Performance) Capture process (Beowulf, Polar Express), Robert Zemeckis has delivered a spectacular and extraordinary new 3D version of the greatest Christmas story of them all. Serving up a great treat for the holidays, the director has brought this Charles Dickens classic to such vivid life that in some ways you feel like you are experiencing it for the first time. With Jim Carrey taking on several roles including Scrooge, this new millennium telling of A Christmas Carol should fill Disney’s coffers with lots of jingle jangle for a very merry box office haul indeed.

Although it may be too dark and scary for the youngest tykes in the family, Zemeckis, who also wrote the adaptation, has effectively gone back to the core of Dicken’s venerable ghost story and married it brilliantly with the hybrid animation process known as Performance Capture. A Christmas Carol has been done to death in so many forms by everyone from Mickey Mouse to Barbie to Mr. Magoo to Bill Murray that this faithful retelling seems oddly overdue. Of course, Disney being Disney and Zemeckis being Zemeckis, it’s been wrapped in a process that takes Scrooge on a state-of-the-art thrill ride, perhaps the greatest time travel story of them all—which is appropriate since it is coming from the creator of the Back To The Future trilogy.

In addition to the remarkable technology on display—a technology that effectively heightens the tale’s fright factor—Jim Carrey is central to this film’s success. He not only takes on the central role of the famous curmudgeon, Ebeneezer Scrooge, but all the Ghosts, Past, Present and Future. Carrey treats the character very seriously, clearly drawing inspiration from Alastair Sim’s interpretation of Scrooge in the 1951 version, still the best live action take on the classic. Carrey’s vocal prowess is rich and varied, lifting the whole enterprise several notches with his amazing performance. Playing all the ghosts is a good idea, as they now logically appear as an extension of Scrooge rather than as intruders. Offering able support in the roles that are left is a stellar cast including Bob Hoskins, taking on both Fezziwig and Old Joe; Gary Oldman in several parts, but most notably as Scooge’s loyal clerk Bob Cratchit; Robin Wright Penn as the lovely Belle and Fan; Cary Elwes in multiple roles; and Colin Firth in only one role, nephew Fred, which he does briefly but quite affably.

The Performance Capture process has advanced leaps and bounds since the dead eye days of Polar Express, and in some cases it’s so realistic you are hard-pressed to believe these actors are being animated. Disney plans to play the picture exclusively in 3D—at least until Avatar comes along to steal many of the screens. In this case, the 3D process is dazzling and entirely appropriate for a highly visual cinematic experience that should keep any bah humbuggers in the audience to a minimum.

Distributor: Walt Disney Pictures
Cast: Jim Carrey, Robin Wright Penn, Bob Hoskins, Cary Elwes, Colin Firth and Gary Oldman.
Director/Screenwriter: Robert Zemeckis
Producers: Robert Zemeckis, Steve Starkey and Jack Rapke
Genre: Animation
Rating: PG for scary sequences and images
Running time: 96 min.
Release date: November 6, 2009

10 Comments

Wickedlycool said:

Sounds promising...

November 3, 2009 6:40 AM

Five Stars said:

Saw an early screening, it's wonderful!

November 3, 2009 11:22 AM

Bubbles said:

i saw pre-screening of the movie on monday 11-2-09 it was really good (: i recommend it to everyone to see it (:

November 4, 2009 4:25 PM

Disgusted said:

Gee... You really liked it. "Zemeckis has delivered a spectacular and extraordinary new 3D version of the greatest Christmas story of them all."
When the publicist asks you for a quote on the movie poster,give em that one, you sell-out.

November 4, 2009 7:36 PM

Disappointed said:

I am disappointed in the 'ad' for this movie. Pete Hammond is quoted as "... new 3D version of the Greatest Christmas Story of All'. I thought the birth of Jesus Christ was. without that 'greatest story' we would no others.

November 6, 2009 7:53 AM

filmfred said:

I have seen it in Germany in 3D. It was a very exciting great movie, more for the older children and also for all adults who love the CHARLES DICKENS
classic story.
The 3D expereience was wonderful. I admire Robert Zemeckis for this great remarkable movie.

November 6, 2009 1:56 PM

Denise said:

Re the earlier opinion about the greatest story of them all. Everyone is entitled to his/her opinion. The birth of Christ may well be the greatest story of them all to Christians but other people have a different view. There is room for us all. I love A Christmas Carol, greatest story, or not.

November 7, 2009 9:53 AM

What's happened to Disney? said:

Filming and Scrooge OK, but overkill on Jim Carrey who becomes extremely tiresome as the ghosts. Also, way too much time on the red-eyed horses and falling down holes and graves. What was with that stupid part about Scrooge shrinking and speaking like a chipmunk? The story was lost in Carrey's personality and the needless length of the aforementioned scenes. Way over dramatized to the point that it made me wish it was over.
And then there was the "contest" for $2,500 that forces you to join twitter in order to enter!

November 8, 2009 11:34 AM

Behnam said:

when could it be downloaded through the internet
in original quality?

November 13, 2009 9:42 AM

Dave in WNY said:

Very impressive movie, saw it at the IMAX in Williamsville, NY today. It takes courage to stick so closely to the book, including the "Old English" that is a bit tough to follow but helps to enrich what is already a very detailed, accurate rendering of the visuals, particularly in the astonishing detail of the major characters, although the minor characters, those that are only on-screen for a few seconds, still look rubber-faced.

If I had to single out one character that moved me more than the rest, I would say it was the Ghost of Christmas Past; there was such a childlike happiness to that character and the embodiment of the desires to return to long-deferred memories of the past. The movie slowed down and took its time when there were good reasons to do so. This movie was well-crafted, by people who really cared about what they were doing and I found it pleasantly refreshing. If you're looking for Scrooge McDuck and comedy, you definitely won't find it here, but if you are looking for a courageous, fresh look at the original book, this adaptation is a definite must-see.

November 14, 2009 2:35 PM

Leave a comment